Sorting game

French exam answers: extra detail that contradicts the text

Spot French reading answers that begin correctly but add a contradiction, using a supplied notice and ten full responses with explicit evidence.

In short

A correct first detail does not cancel a contradictory addition. Check every claim you include against the passage. Supported extra information can remain accurate, but a wrong room, time or condition changes the meaning of the answer. This activity practises textual accuracy, not an official marking formula.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue French to learn

An unnumbered calendar, chair and muted bell above blank paper and a pencil.
Check each added detail against the information supplied. Illustration: Atelier

Atelier de reliure

L’atelier de reliure aura lieu de 10 h à 12 h dans la salle C. Merci d’arriver dix minutes avant le début pour vous installer. Aucun paiement n’est demandé. Le matériel est fourni.

Question for the activity: À quelle heure l’atelier commence-t-il ?

Every response below starts with the correct time. The sorting decision concerns the additional claim. In the first bucket, all the information remains supported. In the second, at least one added detail conflicts with the notice. A concise answer can simply say À 10 h.

Does the whole response remain accurate?

Tap a word, then the box it belongs in.

A small change can alter the instruction

Salle C and salle D differ by one letter, yet direct the reader to different places. Likewise, arriving ten minutes early means 9 h 50, not 10 h 30. The correct start time at the beginning of a sentence does not make either changed instruction harmless.

L’atelier commence à 10 h. Il est demandé d’arriver à 9 h 50.

The workshop begins at ten. Participants are asked to arrive at nine fifty.

Unknown and contradicted are distinct

An unsupported detail such as du café sera offert is not supplied, but it is not directly contradicted either. That still gives you no basis to add it as a fact. This sorting exercise deliberately uses additions that are either supported or contradicted, so the two buckets are clear. In your own response, omit claims you cannot establish.

Question 1No account needed
Which answer is sufficient for the stated question?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

À 10 h.. The first gives the requested time without introducing a contradiction.

Question 2No account needed
Does “Le café sera offert” follow from the notice?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No; the notice does not supply that detail.. Provided materials do not establish refreshments.

Question 3No account needed
Why is “il se termine à 11 h” a contradiction?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Because the notice explicitly says 12 h.. The conflict is with the supplied end time.

When answering a practical reading question, identify the requested fact and include only useful, supported context. This makes your response easier to assess and reduces the chance that an unnecessary claim changes a correct answer into an inaccurate account.