Quiz

Il devrait être arrivé: probability or a missed obligation?

Interpret il devrait être arrivé through timetable evidence, expected completion and reproach, with eight context-based French modal questions.

In short

Il devrait être arrivé can express an expectation that arrival is already complete. A timetable can support “he should have arrived by now”. In a reproachful context where someone is still absent, it can foreground an unmet expected or required arrival. Read the evidence and the interaction.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue French to learn

A person stands near two paths, one leading towards a dotted human outline.
An expected arrival can remain unconfirmed; use the time and context in the written examples. Illustration: Atelier

The conditional devrait qualifies the modal judgement. The past infinitive être arrivé places arrival before the current viewpoint. Those forms alone do not tell you whether the speaker is making a cautious inference, reminding someone of a schedule or blaming them for lateness.

ContextLikely focus
The train arrived an hour ago; the trip home takes twenty minutes.Inference that he is probably home by now.
You were required here at eight; at nine you are still absent.Unmet requirement, potentially reproach.
No timetable, evidence or interaction is given.The reading remains underdetermined.
  1. Question 1No account needed
    “Son train est arrivé à huit heures ; il est neuf heures. Il devrait être arrivé.” What is the main reading?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    An expectation or inference about completed arrival. The timetable and current time support an inference about where he should now be.

  2. Question 2No account needed
    “Tu devrais être arrivé depuis une heure ! Nous t’attendons encore.” What does the reproach foreground?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    An unmet expected arrival. The continuing wait makes the expected arrival unfulfilled and gives the statement a reproachful force.

  3. Question 3No account needed
    Which part names completion before the viewpoint?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    être arrivé. The past infinitive être arrivé presents arrival as completed relative to the viewpoint.

  4. Question 4No account needed
    Does devrait always express moral obligation?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    No, context can make it an epistemic expectation. Devoir can express an inference or expectation as well as obligation.

  5. Question 5No account needed
    “Avec cette correspondance, il devrait être arrivé, mais je n’ai aucune confirmation.” Is arrival established?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    No, it remains an expectation without confirmation. The speaker explicitly lacks confirmation despite the expected timetable.

  6. Question 6No account needed
    Which context most clearly supports a missed obligation?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    A rule required arrival at eight and the person is still absent at nine.. The requirement and continued absence make the unmet obligation explicit.

  7. Question 7No account needed
    What should you do with an isolated “Il devrait être arrivé”?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    Leave the reading dependent on missing context.. The isolated modal permits expectation and other contextual readings; evidence and interaction decide.

  8. Question 8No account needed
    Which English wording often fits the cautious inference?

    Choose one answer.

    Answer and explanation

    He should have arrived by now.. This preserves expected completion without claiming direct confirmation.

Preserve uncertainty in the paraphrase

If the speaker says je n’ai pas de confirmation, retain that limit. Il est arrivé would remove the modal reservation. If the person is visibly still absent and a deadline is invoked, a reproachful reading becomes stronger. The same written sentence can therefore participate in different speech acts without changing its morphology.

D’après l’horaire, il devrait être arrivé ; je vais lui demander confirmation.

According to the timetable, he should have arrived by now; I will ask him to confirm.

Built from