Real document

Read two French transport reports with different publication dates

Compare two French practice reports by publication date, reference period and measurement scope, distinguishing a correction from a new observation.

In short

Compare the reference period and measurement definition before the publication date. A later report can correct an older figure for the same period, or introduce a different period. In this dossier, 121 000 replaces the provisional January count of 120 000; 98 000 covers February and is not a second estimate of January.

Two report folders and blank calendars distinguish an updated figure from a separate reporting period.
Compare reference periods and revision status before comparing totals. Illustration: Atelier

Both reports below concern the same bus operator in this practice dossier. The measured quantity is passenger boardings across the same three lines; one passenger boarding twice contributes two boardings. The documents differ in publication date, revision status and observed month. Keeping those dimensions separate prevents a false contradiction.

Deux rapports · Réseau Val-Rive

Rapport A · publié le 10 février

Période observée : du 1er au 31 janvier. Périmètre : lignes 1, 2 et 3. Indicateur : nombre total de montées à bord. Résultat provisoire : 120 000 montées. Certains relevés du 31 janvier restent à intégrer.

Rapport B · publié le 15 mars

Rectification du bilan de janvier : après intégration des relevés manquants, le total est de 121 000 montées sur les mêmes trois lignes. Ce chiffre remplace le résultat provisoire de 120 000.

Nouveau bilan : du 1er au 28 février, 98 000 montées ont été enregistrées sur les lignes 1, 2 et 3, selon la même définition. Les deux mois n’ont pas le même nombre de jours. Le rapport ne fournit pas de moyenne par jour ni d’analyse des causes.

Practice dossier: distinguish the month measured from the report’s publication date.
Question 1No account needed
Which value should a synthesis use as the corrected January total?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

121 000.. Report B explicitly replaces the provisional January count with 121 000.

Question 2No account needed
What does 98 000 measure?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Total February boardings.. The later report introduces a new February observation using boardings, not distinct people.

Question 3No account needed
Why do 121 000 and 98 000 not contradict each other?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

They describe different months.. The period changes from January to February.

Question 4No account needed
What follows when each total is divided by its stated number of days?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

February averages 3,500 boardings a day, below January’s approximately 3,903.. 121,000 ÷ 31 is approximately 3,903; 98,000 ÷ 28 is 3,500. The supplied figures allow this comparison even though the report does not print the averages. They do not establish the cause of the difference.

Question 5No account needed
Does the report establish a cause for the difference?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No causal analysis is supplied.. The report explicitly leaves causes unanalysed.

Question 6No account needed
Does 121 000 mean 121 000 different people?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No; the indicator counts boardings.. The defined unit is a boarding, so repeat journeys can be counted more than once.

A faithful comparison names the change

Le rapport de mars rectifie le total de janvier à 121 000 montées et présente séparément le bilan de février, établi sur une période plus courte.

The March report corrects January’s total to 121,000 boardings and separately presents February’s count, measured over a shorter period.

This sentence states what is updated and what is new. It does not suggest that the report published in February measures February, or that the March document measures March. Publication and observation dates answer different questions.

The monthly totals alone use unequal durations. Dividing by the supplied day counts gives approximately 3,903 boardings per day in January and 3,500 in February. This calculation supports a lower daily average in February within the stated scope; it does not identify the cause.

When preparing a synthesis, note four items for each figure: period, perimeter, unit and revision status. Compare like with like first. If one changes, describe that change explicitly before drawing a conclusion from the values.

Built from