Myth or fact

Would this French claim survive a change in scale?

Test French claims against neighbourhood measurements, distinguishing absolute changes, geographic extrapolation, annual generalisation and unsupported causality.

In short

Keep the measured place, period, unit and comparison in the conclusion. One week in two neighbourhoods does not establish a region-wide annual result. A before/after change also does not by itself isolate the cause. Changing scale requires additional evidence, not a stronger adjective.

Two small vessels of coloured liquid stand beside a larger jug containing two coloured layers.
The vessels suggest separate and combined scopes; use the table for the actual numerical comparison. Illustration: Atelier

Données de l’exercice · Deux semaines comparées

Périmètre

Consommation d’un même service, dans deux quartiers seulement. Les valeurs sont fournies pour cet exercice. Deux semaines de même durée sont comparées ; aucune autre période n’est fournie. Aucun protocole d’identification causale n’est présenté.

Use these teaching data to test the scope of each claim.
Measurements in the two neighbourhoods
QuartierSemaine de référenceSemaine observée
A100 unités90 unités
B80 unités75 unités

Does the supplied evidence support this claim?

Vrai ou faux ? Decide before you see the verdict.

  1. Dans le quartier A, la consommation mesurée passe de 100 à 90 unités pendant la semaine observée.

  2. Toute la région a réduit sa consommation de 10 % pendant toute l’année.

  3. Le quartier B présente une baisse de 5 unités pendant la même semaine.

  4. La baisse absolue du quartier A est identique à celle du quartier B.

  5. Les deux quartiers additionnés passent de 180 à 165 unités dans le périmètre observé.

  6. Ces seuls relevés prouvent que la mesure a causé toute la baisse.

  7. Une généralisation annuelle demanderait des observations couvrant une période pertinente.

  8. Le périmètre local peut être conservé dans la formulation de la conclusion.

A total reduction and a percentage are different summaries

A falls by 10 units, which is 10 % of its reference value of 100. B falls by 5 units, which is 6.25 % of 80. If combining the neighbourhoods, use the combined reference total rather than averaging the two percentages as if their baselines were equal. The table’s totals are 180 and 165 units. The combined fall is 15/180, approximately 8.33 %.

A geographic or temporal claim needs its own support

The two neighbourhoods do not automatically represent the whole region. The observed week may differ from other weeks through weather, activity or another unreported condition. These possibilities do not prove the local change is false; they limit what the supplied observation can establish beyond itself.

Sur les deux quartiers et les deux semaines comparées, le total passe de 180 à 165 unités ; le dossier ne permet pas d’en déduire un résultat annuel régional.

Across the two neighbourhoods and two compared weeks, the total moves from 180 to 165 units; the dossier does not establish an annual regional result.

Question 1No account needed
Which conclusion preserves the supplied geographic scope?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Dans les deux quartiers observés…. The first names the actually measured locations.

Question 2No account needed
What is the absolute combined fall?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

15 units.. The total falls from 180 to 165, a difference of 15.

Question 3No account needed
Does a scoped conclusion have to deny the local observation?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No; it can report the observation while limiting its extrapolation.. Precision preserves the finding and its boundary.

For an exam reading response, identify which dimension has expanded: place, time, population, outcome or causal force. Then return to the wording the supplied data can support. This gives a concrete reason for challenging the claim.

Built from