Real document

Read a French research chart with error bars and overlapping groups

Read a French research chart whose bars show explicitly defined score ranges. Interpret overlapping ranges without treating them as proof of significance.

In short

Read what the bars represent before interpreting overlap. Here each bar runs from the lowest to the highest observed score, not a confidence interval. Overlap shows shared score ranges; it does not by itself decide statistical significance.

Two empty bowls beneath overlapping abstract coloured ribbons.
Read the legend before interpreting overlapping ranges. Illustration: Atelier

The chart below concerns scores out of twenty in two groups. Its bars are defined as observed minimum-to-maximum ranges. The means and endpoints are supplied in text so the comparison remains readable without relying on an illustration.

Graphique de lecture · score sur 20

Légende

Point centralMoyenne du groupe

BarreDu score minimum observé au score maximum observé

ImportantCes barres ne sont pas des intervalles de confiance

Groupe A

Effectif20 personnes

Moyenne12

Barre minimum–maximum8–16

Groupe B

Effectif20 personnes

Moyenne14

Barre minimum–maximum10–18

Chart values on a common score axis
GroupMinimumMeanMaximum
A81216
B101418
Range plot on a shared zero-to-twenty axis: top blue circle row A spans 8 to 16 with mean 12; bottom terracotta diamond row B spans 10 to 18 with mean 14.
Top blue line and circle: A, range 8–16, mean 12. Bottom terracotta line and diamond: B, range 10–18, mean 14. The shared axis runs from 0 at the left to 20 at the right; each small tick is one point. End caps show observed minima and maxima, and symbols show means. Chart: Atelier · plotted directly from the supplied exercise values

Separate means from individual ranges

B’s mean is two points above A’s mean. The ranges overlap from ten to sixteen. This means some score values lie within both groups’ observed range; it does not mean every participant in B outscored every participant in A. A mean is a group summary, while a range describes its observed extremes.

Question 1No account needed
What do the bars show here?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Observed minimum and maximum. The legend explicitly defines each bar as the minimum-to-maximum observed score range.

Question 2No account needed
What is the mean difference?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Two points. B’s mean is 14 and A’s is 12, so the difference is two points.

Question 3No account needed
Do the bars alone decide statistical significance?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No. These bars show observed ranges. No statistical-test result is supplied, so significance is not determined by overlap alone.

Question 4No account needed
Which claim is unsupported?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Every person in B scores above every person in A. A includes an observed score of16, while B includes10. Those extremes rule out every person in B scoring above every person in A.

La moyenne de B est plus élevée, mais les plages de scores observés se recoupent.

B’s mean is higher, but the observed score ranges overlap.

In another chart, bars might represent standard deviations, standard errors or confidence intervals. Their interpretation would then change. Never transfer this page’s range definition to an unlabelled figure. Ask for the legend and method, then report only the comparison those definitions support.

Built from