Sorting game

Two French sources: agreement about facts, disagreement about action

Sort shared observations, competing explanations and proposed actions in two French sources that agree on counts but disagree about what to do.

In short

Separate the common observation, each explanation and each recommendation. Sharing a statistic does not make the sources’ reasoning or proposed action identical. Attribute the differences: A explique la hausse par… ; B privilégie une autre explication et recommande…

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue French to learn

Two folders share a chart but lead toward publicity and reception options.
Shared observations can lead to different explanations and recommendations. Illustration: Atelier

Deux notes sur un accueil associatif

Constat commun

Les demandes reçues sont passées de 40 à 60 sur deux semaines successives de même durée. Les deux notes reprennent le même registre d’accueil. Aucune enquête sur les motivations des visiteurs n’est présentée.

Source A · Note de communication

A attribue principalement la hausse à une nouvelle affiche installée dans le quartier. La note recommande d’en imprimer davantage pour rendre le service plus visible.

Source B · Note d’organisation

B privilégie la fermeture temporaire d’un service voisin comme explication de la hausse. La note recommande de renforcer l’accueil et de mesurer les temps d’attente avant toute nouvelle campagne.

Practice dossier: the shared register is one underlying source of counts.

What kind of statement is this?

Tap a word, then the box it belongs in.

A common statistic can support different proposals

A sees a successful visibility campaign and wants to expand it. B sees displaced demand and wants to check capacity first. Both cite the same increase. The disagreement therefore concerns explanation and priority, rather than whether the count rose.

Les deux notes s’accordent sur la hausse, mais divergent sur ses causes et sur la réponse à y apporter.

The two notes agree on the increase, but differ over its causes and the response to it.

Preserve the absence of a causal test

Neither note supplies a motivation survey. The dossier therefore does not establish which cause explains most of the increase. It is possible that more than one factor matters, but that possibility is not a measured allocation of causes. A faithful synthesis reports the competing explanations without silently choosing one as a proven fact.

Question 1No account needed
What is shared?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The increase from 40 to 60 requests.. The counts are common; the recommended responses differ.

Question 2No account needed
What kind of statement is “renforcer l’accueil” ?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

A proposed action.. It names what B recommends doing.

Question 3No account needed
Do two notes repeating one register create two independent counts?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No; their count evidence has the same underlying source.. The dossier explicitly identifies one shared register.

Build your synthesis by relation: common finding, explanatory divergence, practical consequences. This shows how the sources connect while leaving each claim with the source that actually makes it.

Built from