Real document

Read a French graph caption that changes the reference year

Read French index captions with different reference years, identifying supported within-series changes and repairing a misleading comparison of raw index levels.

In short

Two index values with different base years do not directly compare the underlying absolute levels. Read base 100 en 2015 and base 100 en 2020 first. Each series tells you change relative to its own reference; the equal index value 120 does not establish equal amounts.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue French to learn

The upper index line has three points, with its first point circled. The lower has two points and begins at the middle date of the upper line.
The upper series is A: 100 in 2015, 120 in 2020, 126 in 2023. The lower is B: 100 in 2020, 120 in 2023. Circles mark each series’ own base; the dates align, but underlying amounts are not supplied. Teaching diagram: Atelier

A report places two series beside each other. The numbers look comparable because both are called indices, but their captions define different starting points. Treat the caption as part of the evidence. The following extract supplies no underlying euro amounts, household counts or conversion between the series.

Deux séries, deux bases

Série A · indice base 100 en 2015

2015100

2020120

2023126

Série B · indice base 100 en 2020

2020100

2023120

Commentaire à examiner

Phrase proposéeEn 2020, le niveau de A est supérieur de 20 % au niveau de B.

Teaching indices: the underlying quantities are not supplied.

What the labels support

For A, the value 120 in 2020 represents a 20% rise from A’s own 2015 reference. For B, 120 in 2023 represents a 20% rise from B’s own 2020 reference. A moves from 120 to 126 between 2020 and 2023, a 5% increase relative to 120, not a 6% increase relative to that date. Six is the change in index points.

Question 1No account needed
What does A = 120 in 2020 establish?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

A is 20% above its own 2015 base.. The caption defines A’s reference as 2015.

Question 2No account needed
Can the proposed cross-series absolute comparison be established?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No. Different base years and absent underlying values prevent that conclusion.

Question 3No account needed
From 120 to 126, what is the percentage increase?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

5%. The increase is 6/120, or 5%.

Question 4No account needed
What does the movement from 120 to 126 equal in index points?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

6 points. Index points are the arithmetic difference between the displayed index values.

En 2020, l’indice A dépasse de 20 % sa base de 2015 ; les données ne permettent pas de comparer les niveaux absolus de A et de B.

In 2020, index A is 20% above its 2015 base; the data do not allow a comparison of A and B’s absolute levels.

A careful rewrite preserves what can be established and names what remains unavailable. Before paraphrasing a graph caption, record the unit, base year, covered period and comparison intended. A clean layout cannot substitute for those definitions.

Built from